Click to compare: Is car insurance cheaper online?

Click to compare Is car insurance cheaper online?

By Jackie Pearson
7 January 2009


A number of new online car insurance brands have popped up recently but do your research to ensure you don’t sacrifice service and coverage for a cheaper premium.

In addition to the long-established insurers that are household names in Australia, there are currently around a dozen ‘fresh’ brands specialising in providing online quotes and the ability to purchase, amend and renew your car insurance online.

They all promise cheap coverage by offering more comprehensive underwriting or techniques to calculate premiums more accurately.

compare and buy car insurance online

Image by Mr. Imperial

Some sites even look low-budget and point out that they don’t spend money on things like printing fancy marketing brochures as a way of keeping your premiums low.


There are only around five underwriters behind the dozen online brands.  Auto and General Insurance, for example, underwrites policies for Budget Direct, 1cover, 1300Insurance, 1stforwomen, Cashbank Car Insurance and Ozicare.

Just Car Insurance and Bingle are underwritten by AAMI. eCar policies are backed by “various Lloyds underwriters”. Real Insurance and PayAsYouDrive are brands for the Hollard insurance group. And Secure Motor Plus is underwritten by Vero.

The online brands are a marketing tool for the underwriters as they appeal to a more specific “niche” in the market such as women (1stforwomen) or young drivers (Just Car Insurance).

Developing policies for specific types of policyholder should enable them to bring prices down.

1stforwomen, for example, claims that because women have better driving records than men their “good quality” drivers don’t have to “pay a higher premium to subsidise drivers that represent a higher risk”.


There are substantial price differences between the online players so don’t assume your first online quote will deliver the cheapest deal. Online quotes for a Tarago-driving netball mum with a learner driver found the cheapest premium with Youi at $76.46 per month and the most expensive from Bingle at $354.53 per month – that’s a saving of over $3000 per year.

 Some online brands make money by charging a margin on top of the base premium. Most have an additional charge if you elect to pay monthly. Brands from the same underwriter offer different prices.


Cheap cover can come with restrictions so it is imperative to read the fine-print. Youi, for example, won’t pay a claim for damage caused by a household member who is not listed as a driver on your policy schedule.

Its cover for emergency accommodation, transport or emergency repairs if you are more than 100km from home is $100 per day up to $300 per claim, which is substantially lower than some other policies.

The No Claim discounts or ratings offered by online brands may not be as generous as those available from longer-standing operators or you may have to pay extra to protect your No Claim status.

eCar and Real Insurance have strict underwriting conditions that mean you will not qualify online for their coverage if, for example, you are attempting to insure a young driver. Real Insurance does encourage you to telephone for assistance if you are declined coverage online.

Some online brands won’t insure you online if your car is used for business, if it is modified or has non-standard accessories or if a driver has made multiple claims in the past five years.


Some major insurers are now offering further discounts on comprehensive car insurance policies and renewals if you purchase online. There are plenty of savings to take advantage of if you click and compare, so be sure to do your own comparisons or use a comparison site such as RateCity that comprehensively covers the market.

Related Links


Did you find this helpful? Why not share this article?



Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy


Learn more about car insurance

Does insurance cover a stolen car if keys were in the car?

A car insurance policy that covers the theft of your car, such as third party fire and theft insurance, usually covers a stolen car, even if the keys were in the car’s ignition.

However, your insurer may deny the claim if you live in an area where there have been several car robberies reported recently. They will see you leaving the keys in the car as a case of negligence. In such cases, your insurance provider may even expect you to have installed anti-theft security measures in your car. 

You may need to confirm whether or not you left your keys in your car, and if they had been stolen or misplaced, before filing your car insurance claim. The loss or theft of your car keys may be covered by a comprehensive car insurance policy, but usually as an optional item.

If you can confirm that your car keys were stolen, mention this in your claim as this will help establish that your car was not stolen as a result of your negligence.

Can you insure your car for 6 months?

Most Australian insurers won’t offer you a 6-month car insurance policy, so you may need to buy a policy that covers your car for damages and cancel it after six months. You will need to purchase comprehensive car insurance to protect your car from accidental damage, theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.. 

Consider checking whether your 6-month comprehensive car insurance will cost more if you pay monthly or six-monthly premiums instead of a one-time annual premium. Another question to ask the insurer is whether you’ll need to pay administration or cancellation fees when you cancel the policy.

Alternatively, you can look for a suitable ‘pay as you drive’ car insurance policy, which usually offers you the coverage of a comprehensive car insurance policy but only requires you to pay for the distance driven. Such a policy may not be the ideal 6-month car insurance plan as it is based on how much you drive rather than for how long. If you need to drive a lot, you may end up paying more than you’d pay for regular car insurance.