Auction v private sale: how to create a bidding war

Auction v private sale: how to create a bidding war

If you’re thinking of selling your home now may be the time to do it as buyers flood back into the market, according to experts.

“People are buying homes in steadily growing numbers,” said property expert Terry Ryder, founder of 

All indicators point to a healthy home buyer market: a strong economy, low interest rates, solid population growth, recovering property markets, a high level of government assistance for people building new homes.

But when it comes to maximising your sale price is it better to sell by auction or private treaty?

If you ask the experts some say the competitive atmosphere of an auction guarantees the best price. Others warn that auctions are fraught with danger and a private treaty sale is the most effective way to wring every last dollar out of a buyer.

Going once, twice…sold!

One good thing about auction is it entices buyers before a price is determined without putting people off with a set figure.

“Auction is ideal for homes where you consider there will be more than one interested buyer,” property expert John McGrath told Money magazine.

It can also suit properties which have unique selling points, like a great view, which can be hard to value so a healthy bidding war will often bring the highest price, he said.

The auctions market has continued to show signs of ongoing strength, with clearance rates – the percentage of homes that sell at auction – remaining above 60 percent in the major capital cities, according to RP Data’s October figures.

But selling at auction isn’t for every property, according to Andrew Winter, host of Foxtel’s Selling Houses Australia.

When private treaty sale is best

“If your property is stock standard, private treaty is often the best option. Buyers already know its value so you’re unlikely to get a higher price and it’s a lot less stress,” he said.

“Auctions can be expensive, but they don’t always cost more than private treaty. If a place has been on the market for many, many months the marketing bills can soon mount up.”

Selling by private treaty could cost around $180 a week in newspaper ads plus $350 for the for sale sign, according to Winter. By comparison, an auction will set you back around $6000 to $10,000, including a four-week marketing campaign.

Another difference between private treaty and auction is time.

“Even if a property is passed in, an auction is an easy way to identify serious buyers for further negotiations. But on the downside, if there are no bidders you’ve just wasted a big chunk of cash,” Winter said.

For some people, the stress of auction is too much to bear, according to McGrath.

“I’ve come across situations where the house was suited to auction but the vendor wasn’t. Some vendors are also uncomfortable with the public nature of auctions. They don’t want everyone knowing how much they received for their home,” he said.

In these cases, private treaty provides that discretion and allows you much more time to consider offers from potential buyers.

If in doubt, speak to your agent, says McGrath: “Ask them to explain why they’ve recommended a particular method of sale and be honest about your feelings. It’s part of an agent’s job to support you through the process so feel free to share your concerns.”

Did you find this helpful? Why not share this article?



Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy


Learn more about home loans

What is bridging finance?

A loan of shorter duration taken to buy a new property before a borrower sells an existing property, usually taken to cover the financial gap that occurs while buying a new property without first selling an older one.

Usually, these loans have higher interest rates and a shorter repayment duration.

Mortgage Calculator, Property Value

An estimate of how much your desired property is worth. 

Mortgage Calculator, Repayment Frequency

How often you wish to pay back your lender. 

How often is your data updated?

We work closely with lenders to get updates as quick as possible, with updates made the same day wherever possible.

What is the ratings scale?

The ratings are between 0 and 5, shown to one decimal point, with 5.0 as the best. The ratings should be used as an easy guide rather than the only thing you consider. For example, a product with a rating of 4.7 may or may not be better suited to your needs than one with a rating of 4.5, but both are probably much better than one with a rating of 1.2.

Do other comparison sites offer the same service?

Real Time RatingsTM is the only online system that ranks the home loan market based on your personal borrowing preferences. Until now, home loans have been rated based on outdated data. Our system is unique because it reacts to changes as soon as we update our database.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Results

These are the loans that may be suitable, based on your pre-selected criteria. 

How does a redraw facility work?

A redraw facility attached to your loan allows you to borrow back any additional repayments that you have already paid on your loan. This can be a beneficial feature because, by paying down the principal with additional repayments, you will be charged less interest. However you will still be able to access the extra money when needed.

Why should you trust Real Time Ratings?

Real Time Ratings™ was conceived by a team of data experts who have been analysing trends and behaviour in the home loan market for more than a decade. It was designed purely to meet the evolving needs of home loan customers who wish to merge low cost with flexible features quickly. We believe it fills a glaring gap in the market by frequently re-rating loan products based on the changes lenders make daily.

Real Time Ratings™ is a new idea and will change over time to match the frequently-evolving demands of the market. Some things won’t change though – it will always rate all relevent products in our database and will not be influenced by advertising.

If you have any feedback about Real Time Ratings™, please get in touch.

Remaining loan term

The length of time it will take to pay off your current home loan, based on the currently-entered mortgage balance, monthly repayment and interest rate.

Monthly Repayment

Your current monthly home loan repayment. To accurately calculate how much you could save, an accurate payment figure is required. If you are not certain, check your bank statement.

Mortgage Calculator, Repayments

The money you pay back to your lender at regular intervals. 

What do mortgage brokers do?

Mortgage brokers are finance professionals who help borrowers organise home loans with lenders. As such, they act as middlemen between borrowers and lenders.

While bank staff recommend home loan products only from their own employer, brokers are independent, so they can recommend products from a range of institutions.

Brokers need to be accredited with a particular lender to be able to work with that lender. A typical broker will be accredited with anywhere from 10 to 30 lenders – the big four banks, as well as a range of smaller banks, credit unions and non-bank lenders.

As a general rule, brokers don’t charge consumers for their services; instead, they receive commissions from lenders whenever they place a borrower with that institution.

What is appraised value?

An estimation of a property’s value before beginning the mortgage approval process. An appraiser (or valuer) is an expert who estimates the value of a property. The lender generally selects the appraiser or valuer before sanctioning the loan.