ASIC kept in the dark on scrapping responsible lending rules

ASIC kept in the dark on scrapping responsible lending rules

Financial regulators weren’t asked for their assessment on the scrapping of responsible lending laws before the government’s surprise announcement, according to testimony, leaving the head of a leading regulator to learn about the controversial decision in media reports.

Commissioners from ASIC and APRA were questioned about the scrapping of responsible lending laws before a parliamentary committee last week, where they revealed they were given little-to-no notice and were not asked for their views on the decision.

“When was ASIC first informed of the government's intention to scrap responsible lending obligations?,” Dr Andrew Leigh asked, shadow treasurer for Labor.

“I'm the commissioner with responsibility for credit,” Sean Hughes replied, commissioner at ASIC, “and I was first advised when I read the Treasurer's media statement through the media on the morning of 25 September.”

“That's extraordinary,” Dr Leigh replied. “So you got no heads-up ... You weren't asked to provide any advice.”

ASIC is responsible for making sure lenders fulfil their responsible lending obligations (RLO), laws introduced after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) that require them to verify a person can afford to repay the debt they’re being sold.

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg announced the consumer protections would be reformed in a media release and an op-ed published in The Australian on September 25.

Surprise testimony

Mr Hughes was prompted to answer the question after ASIC’s chair, James Shipton, announced he was stepping aside following an investigation into the claiming of relocation costs totalling $118,000.

“I'm speaking on my own behalf as the responsible commissioner for this area,” Mr Hughes said. “I don't know whether there were communications between the Treasurer and his office and Mr Shipton.”

ASIC did not respond to questions clarifying if Mr Shipton was consulted on the decision to scrap responsible lending laws.

Treasury said a “targeted public consultation” was undertaken after the announcement was made, but they did not disclose the stakeholders involved when asked. There is no consultation posting for the credit reforms on Treasury’s website.

“The timing of any public consultation on draft legislation is a matter for Government,” a Treasury spokesperson told RateCity.

Treasurer Frydenberg quoted select public testimony of RBA chair Philip Lowe in his announcement.

RateCity asked the RBA if they had been included as part of consultation. The nation’s central bank declined to provide a comment.

Going against past recommendations

Dr Leigh observed the government’s decision to scrap responsible lending obligations contradicts an ASIC parliamentary submission made in March 2017. The submission found the “credit reforms (including RLOs) have gone a long way towards addressing many of the issues that were prevalent throughout the credit industry before 2010”.

“Would you agree that ASIC's 2017 Senate submission would contradict the government's decision to scrap responsible lending obligations?,” Dr Leigh asked.

Mr Hughes said he could not comment on the report as he was not a commission member at the time.

He referred again to the Treasurer’s statement on 25 September, and said it was clear they believed the policy was necessary to address the economic impacts of the pandemic.

“From ASIC's point of view, we're just getting on with the instructions we've been given to support Treasury in implementing those reforms,” Mr Hughes said.

APRA was not ‘advocating change’

The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) was later questioned on the notice they were given ahead of the news that responsible lending laws would be scrapped.

“I think we learnt in early August that the government was thinking of making changes and was considering what options might be possible,” Wayne Byres said, chair of APRA.

“... (Treasurer Frydenberg) asked me (in September) some questions about APRA, APRA standards and options for how APRA standards might be applied. That's what I gave advice on.”

Dr Leigh questioned if APRA provided any policy or impact analysis of the changes. “Did you look, for example, at how it would impact low- and middle-income households?,” he asked.

Mr Byres said “(APRA) didn't provide advice on that”.

Dr Leigh asked for APRA’s position on the scrapping of responsible lending laws.

“We were not advocating change”, Dr Byres said.

What scrapping the rules could mean for Australians

The announcement to scrap responsible lending rules has proven divisive. Businesses generally hailed people’s ability to secure credit easier, while four consumer groups banded together in opposition, warning it’ll result in more people holding debt they can’t afford.

The governance born from the Global Financial Crisis and Royal Commission into banking highlighted the need for responsible lending practices, Sally Tindall said, research director at RateCity.

“There’s no question the work of ASIC and APRA to improve the quality of bank’s home loan books over the last 10 years has put a lot of Australians in a much better position to ride out the COVID storm,” she said.

“The last thing we want is to go back to the bad old days where people find themselves in loans they can’t repay.”

Shadow Treasurer Andrew Leigh questioned the decision to scrap responsible lending practices.

“It’s astonishing that the government didn’t even consult ASIC and APRA before making a major change to responsible lending laws,” he told RateCity.

“Consumer groups have warned that these changes could cause significant harm.

“With Australian household debt loads among the highest in the world, does the economy really need more irresponsible lending?”


Did you find this helpful? Why not share this news?



Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy


Learn more about home loans

What is a fixed home loan?

A fixed rate home loan is a loan where the interest rate is set for a certain amount of time, usually between one and 15 years. The advantage of a fixed rate is that you know exactly how much your repayments will be for the duration of the fixed term. There are some disadvantages to fixing that you need to be aware of. Some products won’t let you make extra repayments, or offer tools such as an offset account to help you reduce your interest, while others will charge a significant break fee if you decide to terminate the loan before the fixed period finishes.

What is a redraw fee?

Redraw fees are charged by your lender when you want to take money you have already paid into your mortgage back out. Typically, banks will only allow you to take money out of your loan if you have a redraw facility attached to your loan, and the money you are taking out is part of any additional repayments you’ve made. The average redraw fee is around $19 however there are plenty of lenders who include a number of fee-free redraws a year. Tip: Negative-gearers beware – any money redrawn is often treated as new borrowing for tax purposes, so there may be limits on how you can use it if you want to maximise your tax deduction.

Interest Rate

Your current home loan interest rate. To accurately calculate how much you could save, an accurate interest figure is required. If you are not certain, check your bank statement or log into your mortgage account.

Mortgage Calculator, Repayment Frequency

How often you wish to pay back your lender. 

Remaining loan term

The length of time it will take to pay off your current home loan, based on the currently-entered mortgage balance, monthly repayment and interest rate.

Why is it important to get the most up-to-date information?

The mortgage market changes constantly. Every week, new products get launched and existing products get tweaked. Yet many ratings and awards systems rank products annually or biannually.

We update our product data as soon as possible when lenders make changes, so if a bank hikes its interest rates or changes its product, the system will quickly re-evaluate it.

Nobody wants to read a weather forecast that is six months old, and the same is true for home loan comparisons.

What is the average annual percentage rate?

Also known as the comparison rate, or sometimes the ‘true rate’ of a loan, the average annual percentage rate (AAPR) is used to indicate the overall cost of a loan after considering all the fees, charges and other factors, such as introductory offers and honeymoon rates.

The AAPR is calculated based on a standardised loan amount and loan term, and doesn’t include any extra non-standard charges.

How is the flexibility score calculated?

Points are awarded for different features. More important features get more points. The points are then added up and indexed into a score from 0 to 5.

What is an ombudsman?

An complaints officer – previously referred to as an ombudsman -looks at formal complaints from customers about their credit providers, and helps to find a fair and independent solution to these problems.

These services are handled by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, a non-profit government organisation that addresses and resolves financial disputes between customers and financial service providers.

How personalised is my rating?

Real Time Ratings produces instant scores for loan products and updates them based what you tell us about what you’re looking for in a loan. In that sense, we believe the ratings are as close as you get to personalised; the more you tell us, the more we customise to ratings to your needs. Some borrowers value flexibility, while others want the lowest cost loan. Your preferences will be reflected in the rating. 

We also take a shorter term, more realistic view of how long borrowers hold onto their loan, which gives you a better idea about the true borrowing costs. We take your loan details and calculate how much each of the relevent loans would cost you on average each month over the next five years. We assess the overall flexibility of each loan and give you an easy indication of which ones are likely to adjust to your needs over time. 

Do other comparison sites offer the same service?

Real Time RatingsTM is the only online system that ranks the home loan market based on your personal borrowing preferences. Until now, home loans have been rated based on outdated data. Our system is unique because it reacts to changes as soon as we update our database.

What is a building in course of erection loan?

Also known as a construction home loan, a building in course of erection (BICOE) loan loan allows you to draw down funds as a building project advances in order to pay the builders. This option is available on selected variable rate loans.

Mortgage Calculator, Interest Rate

The percentage of the loan amount you will be charged by your lender to borrow. 

Does Real Time Ratings' work for people who already have a home loan?

Yes. If you already have a mortgage you can use Real Time RatingsTM to compare your loan against the rest of the market. And if your rate changes, you can come back and check whether your loan is still competitive. If it isn’t, you’ll get the ammunition you need to negotiate a rate cut with your lender, or the resources to help you switch to a better lender.