Do Australians prefer banks to brokers?

Do Australians prefer banks to brokers?

With sweeping changes to mortgage broker remuneration on the table in the wake of the recent banking royal commission, new figures indicate that Australian mortgage holders may be more satisfied with their experience when applying for a mortgage directly through a bank branch.

According to the Roy Morgan Single Source Survey, home loan customers who obtained their loan in person at a bank branch enjoyed a 77.2% satisfaction rating, compared to 75.1% satisfaction for those who used a mortgage broker. Even when looking solely at recent home loans from the past 6 years, satisfaction with going to a branch to obtain the loan was 79.8% compared to 77.7% for mortgage brokers.

However, outpacing both brokers and branches was mobile bank representatives. Mortgage holders who obtained their home loan by meeting in person with a mobile bank representative enjoyed a satisfaction rate of 80.6%, according to Roy Morgan.

Which banks get more satisfaction from brokers over branches?

While the survey found that on average, mortgage holders enjoy greater overall satisfaction from dealing with mobile bank representatives and branches compared to dealing with brokers, it also found that customers were more satisfied with brokers than branches when applying for home loans from selected lenders, including St.George, Bankwest and NAB.

Home loan customer satisfaction

Bank Home loan through branch Home loan through mortgage broker
Bendigo Bank 89.6% N/A
St.George 79.6% 83.9%
Suncorp Bank 79.1% 72.6%
ANZ 76.5% 67.3%
Bankwest 76.3% 81.0%
Westpac 72.0% 65.8%
CBA 71.4% 67.1%
NAB 70.8% 71.7%

Roy Morgan industry communication director, Norman Morris, said:

“Although mortgage brokers have had a number of negative issues highlighted by the Royal Commission, there is a large variation in their satisfaction across the major banks and as a result there will be lessons to be learnt by understanding the better performers.”

Are brokers or branches more popular?

While mobile bank representatives enjoyed higher satisfaction scores in the Roy Morgan survey compared to branches and brokers, these representatives were found to be responsible for signing a relatively small fraction of Australia’s home loans. 

The survey found that over half (53.1%) of all current mortgages were obtained in person at a bank branch, while approximately one third (33.4%) were purchased through a mortgage broker, and just 8.1% were obtained in person with a mobile bank representative.  

Method used to obtain loan Percentage
In person at a branch 53.1%
Mortgage broker 33.4%
In person with a mobile bank representative 8.1%
Over the phone 3.1%
Other 2.3%

Did you find this helpful? Why not share this news?

Advertisement

RateCity

Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the ratecity.com.au Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy

Advertisement

Learn more about home loans

Who offers 40 year mortgages?

Home loans spanning 40 years are offered by select lenders, though the loan period is much longer than a standard 30-year home loan. You're more likely to find a maximum of 35 years, such as is the case with Teacher’s Mutual Bank

Currently, 40 year home loan lenders in Australia include AlphaBeta Money, BCU, G&C Mutual Bank, Pepper, and Sydney Mutual Bank.

Even though these lengthier loans 35 to 40 year loans do exist on the market, they are not overwhelmingly popular, as the extra interest you pay compared to a 30-year loan can be over $100,000 or more.

Mortgage Calculator, Repayments

The money you pay back to your lender at regular intervals. 

Mortgage Calculator, Interest Rate

The percentage of the loan amount you will be charged by your lender to borrow. 

What is a redraw fee?

Redraw fees are charged by your lender when you want to take money you have already paid into your mortgage back out. Typically, banks will only allow you to take money out of your loan if you have a redraw facility attached to your loan, and the money you are taking out is part of any additional repayments you’ve made. The average redraw fee is around $19 however there are plenty of lenders who include a number of fee-free redraws a year. Tip: Negative-gearers beware – any money redrawn is often treated as new borrowing for tax purposes, so there may be limits on how you can use it if you want to maximise your tax deduction.

Why is it important to get the most up-to-date information?

The mortgage market changes constantly. Every week, new products get launched and existing products get tweaked. Yet many ratings and awards systems rank products annually or biannually.

We update our product data as soon as possible when lenders make changes, so if a bank hikes its interest rates or changes its product, the system will quickly re-evaluate it.

Nobody wants to read a weather forecast that is six months old, and the same is true for home loan comparisons.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Term

How long you wish to take to pay off your loan. 

Do other comparison sites offer the same service?

Real Time RatingsTM is the only online system that ranks the home loan market based on your personal borrowing preferences. Until now, home loans have been rated based on outdated data. Our system is unique because it reacts to changes as soon as we update our database.

What is the flexibility score?

Today’s home loans often try to lure borrowers with a range of flexible features, including offset accounts, redraw facilities, repayment frequency options, repayment holidays, split loan options and portability. Real Time Ratings™ weights each of these features based on popularity and gives loans a ‘flexibility score’ based on how much they cater to borrowers’ needs over time. The aim is to give a higher score to loans which give borrowers more features and options.

What is the average annual percentage rate?

Also known as the comparison rate, or sometimes the ‘true rate’ of a loan, the average annual percentage rate (AAPR) is used to indicate the overall cost of a loan after considering all the fees, charges and other factors, such as introductory offers and honeymoon rates.

The AAPR is calculated based on a standardised loan amount and loan term, and doesn’t include any extra non-standard charges.

What is appreciation or depreciation of property?

The increase or decrease in the value of a property due to factors including inflation, demand and political stability.

Does each product always have the same rating?

No, the rating you see depends on a number of factors and can change as you tell us more about your loan profile and preferences. The reasons you may see a different rating:

  • Lenders have made changes. Our ratings show the relative competitiveness of all the products listed at a given time. As the listing change, so do the ratings.
  • You have updated you profile. If you increase your loan amount, the impact of different rates and fees will change which loans are the lowest cost for you.
  • You adjust your preferences. The more you search for flexible loan features, the more importance we assign to the Flexibility Score. You can also adjust your Flexibility Weighting yourself, which will recalculate the ratings with preference given to more flexible loans.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Amount

How much you intend to borrow. 

How often is your data updated?

We work closely with lenders to get updates as quick as possible, with updates made the same day wherever possible.

How will Real Time Ratings help me find a new home loan?

The home loan market is complex. With almost 4,000 different loans on offer, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to work out which loans work for you.

That’s where Real Time RatingsTM can help. Our system automatically filters out loans that don’t fit your requirements and ranks the remaining loans based on your individual loan requirements and preferences.

Best of all, the ratings are calculated in real time so you know you’re getting the most current information.