Lenders take opposing views on bank levy

Lenders take opposing views on bank levy

The Major Bank Levy has been passed in Australia’s Lower House today, following a recent Senate committee hearing and inquiry that saw a variety of banks, financial institutions and economic commentators have their say.

The levy is set to raise over $6 billion from Australia’s leading banks, which could have a knock-on effect on on home loan interest rates, fees, and other banking charges. 

For the Levy
Against the Levy
  • The Big Four (Westpac, ANZ, NAB and CBA)
  • Macquarie Bank
  • Australian Bankers Association
  • SIFSA
  • Finance Sector Union
  • Business Council of Australia

 

For the levy

Several of the non-major banks and consumer-owned financial institutions came out in favour of the levy, supporting a levelling of the playing field with banks that are “too big to fail”, and encouraging competition.

BOQ supports the Levy as a step towards a more competitive banking system as it properly recognises the major banks’ too-big-to-fail funding advantage that they enjoy.”

Suncorp said that while it does not generally support new or increased taxes on Australian businesses, it welcomes any initiative which helps to improve competitive neutrality in the banking sector.

While Bendigo and Adelaide Bank expressed its support of the levy, it also acknowledged its issues, and voiced its support of a considered approach to its legislation and implementation.

Against the levy

As expected, Australia’s Big Four banks came out swinging against the levy, proposing a number of amendments, including:

Introducing a sunset clause for the levy (e.g. when the budget returns to surplus)

  • Extending the levy to consistently cover foreign banks
  • Reviewing the legislation once a number of years have passed
  • Adding a mechanism to suspend the levy in the event of financial stress

In addition, among NAB’s objections to the levy were concerns of what impact it may have on Australia’s economy as a whole from an international perspective:

“Interest in the levy has been significant and largely negative in the context of it raising political risks associated with the operation of the Australian financial system and the general attractiveness of Australia as an investment destination.”

While ANZ opposed the levy, it acknowledged its commitment to rebuilding trust with the Parliament and the community, and accepted that the levy would pass into law.

The fifth bank set to be affect by the levy, Macquarie Bank, argued that it shouldn’t be counted as a “major bank”, due to domestic banking making up a small percentage of its wider investment and wholesale financial operations.

The Australian Bankers Association acknowledged its support for a strong and competitive banking industry, noting that several non-major banks supported the proposed levy in order to create a more level playing field.  

However, the ABA also described consultation for the bank levy as “rushed and inadequate”, expressing concern that the brunt of the levy’s costs would be borne by a combination of savers, borrowers, shareholders, employees and suppliers, and that imposing a levy on profitable institutions sets a worrying precedent for other successful Australian businesses.

The Business Council of Australia echoed these concerns:

“The levy is poor public policy, the problems of which have been compounded by poor process. Both the policy and the way it was introduced increase sovereign risk, undermine investor confidence and raise the question – which industry is next? The levy also represents another ‘one-off’ in a long line of ‘one-offs’ that undermine investor confidence.”

Other organisations voiced concerns regarding the levy’s potential impact on other aspects of the Australian economy. According to the Self-managed Independent Superannuation Funds Association, the bank levy will cause collateral damage to 27 million superannuation account holders whose funds invest heavily in bank shares, and a further one million with accounts in self-managed funds.

Having passed the House of Representatives, the Major Bank Levy is set to go to the Senate before the end of the week.

Did you find this helpful? Why not share this news?

Advertisement

RateCity

Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the ratecity.com.au Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy

Advertisement

Learn more about home loans

What is a specialist lender?

Specialist lenders, also known as non-conforming lenders, are lenders that offer mortgages to ‘non-vanilla’ borrowers who struggle to get finance at mainstream banks.

That includes people with bad credit, as well as borrowers who are self-employed, in casual employment or are new to Australia.

Specialist lenders take a much more flexible approach to assessing mortgage applications than mainstream banks.

Mortgage Calculator, Interest Rate

The percentage of the loan amount you will be charged by your lender to borrow. 

Mortgage Calculator, Repayments

The money you pay back to your lender at regular intervals. 

What is breach of contract?

A failure to follow all or part of a contract or breaking the conditions of a contract without any legal excuse. A breach of contract can be material, minor, actual or anticipatory, depending on the severity of the breaches and their material impact.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Results

These are the loans that may be suitable, based on your pre-selected criteria. 

Who offers 40 year mortgages?

Home loans spanning 40 years are offered by select lenders, though the loan period is much longer than a standard 30-year home loan. You're more likely to find a maximum of 35 years, such as is the case with Teacher’s Mutual Bank

Currently, 40 year home loan lenders in Australia include AlphaBeta Money, BCU, G&C Mutual Bank, Pepper, and Sydney Mutual Bank.

Even though these lengthier loans 35 to 40 year loans do exist on the market, they are not overwhelmingly popular, as the extra interest you pay compared to a 30-year loan can be over $100,000 or more.

Savings over

Select a number of years to see how much money you can save with different home loans over time.

e.g. To see how much you could save in two years by switching mortgages,  set the slider to 2.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Term

How long you wish to take to pay off your loan. 

What is an ombudsman?

An complaints officer – previously referred to as an ombudsman -looks at formal complaints from customers about their credit providers, and helps to find a fair and independent solution to these problems.

These services are handled by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, a non-profit government organisation that addresses and resolves financial disputes between customers and financial service providers.

What happens to your mortgage when you die?

There is no hard and fast answer to what will happen to your mortgage when you die as it is largely dependent on what you have set out in your mortgage agreement, your will (if you have one), other assets you may have and if you have insurance. If you have co-signed the mortgage with another person that person will become responsible for the remaining debt when you die.

If the mortgage is in your name only the house will be sold by the bank to cover the remaining debt and your nominated air will receive the remaining sum if there is a difference. If there is a turn in the market and the sale of your house won’t cover the remaining debt the case may go to court and the difference may have to be covered by the sale of other assets.  

If you have a life insurance policy your family may be able to use some of the lump sum payment from this to pay down the remaining mortgage debt. Alternatively, your lender may provide some form of mortgage protection that could assist your family in making repayments following your passing.

What factors does Real Time Ratings consider?

Real Time RatingsTM uses a range of information to provide personalised results:

  • Your loan amount
  • Your borrowing status (whether you are an owner-occupier or an investor)
  • Your loan-to-value ratio (LVR)
  • Your personal preferences (such as whether you want an offset account or to be able to make extra repayments)
  • Product information (such as a loan’s interest rate, fees and LVR requirements)
  • Market changes (such as when new loans come on to the market)

Does Real Time Ratings' work for people who already have a home loan?

Yes. If you already have a mortgage you can use Real Time RatingsTM to compare your loan against the rest of the market. And if your rate changes, you can come back and check whether your loan is still competitive. If it isn’t, you’ll get the ammunition you need to negotiate a rate cut with your lender, or the resources to help you switch to a better lender.

What is appreciation or depreciation of property?

The increase or decrease in the value of a property due to factors including inflation, demand and political stability.

How is the flexibility score calculated?

Points are awarded for different features. More important features get more points. The points are then added up and indexed into a score from 0 to 5.