RBA makes the case for 20-storey apartments in Sydney

RBA makes the case for 20-storey apartments in Sydney

Planning controls -- and not demand -- have pushed the price of apartments in Sydney up by more than half of their construction costs, Australia’s central bank has found.

The average sale price of an apartment in Sydney was $873,000 in 2018, when the Reserve Bank estimates it cost $519,000 to build. The difference of $355,000 -- or 68 per cent -- is the result of red tape prohibiting the development of taller apartments in areas where the demand is high.

That’s the headline takeaway from the Reserve Bank’s research discussion paper, The Apartment Shortage, which measured the excess demand for apartments in Australia’s largest cities.

Buildings are going up, but not where needed

The analysis found similar patterns in Australia's other east coast cities, though they were not nearly as pronounced. Melbourne apartments sold for $588,000 on average a couple of years ago and cost $491,000 to build. The difference of $97,000 amounted to a margin of 20 per cent.

Brisbane property prices by comparison fared far less lucrative. An average apartment sold for $470,000 when it cost $460,000 to build, the difference of $10,000 working out to be a cost margin of just 2 per cent.

People wanted to live in the city, but apartments were being built elsewhere, authors Keaton Jenner and Peter Tulip wrote.

“Even though the excess demand for apartments is greatest near the centre, building patterns do not reflect this,” they said.

“Recent and planned construction in Sydney is located predominantly in middle and outer suburbs.

“In Melbourne and Brisbane the effect was unevenly spread throughout the metropolitan areas.”

Taller apartments would circumvent excess land costs, the authors wrote, but they warned these savings would be eroded if the buildings became too tall.

“For short buildings, land costs amount to hundreds of thousands of dollars per apartment,” they wrote. 

“As building height increases, however, the per-apartment cost of land declines while construction costs increase.”

They said doubling the typical height of apartment buildings in Sydney from ten to 20-storeys, at most, would help eat into the 68 per cent margin and make city housing more affordable.

Inner Sydney apartments should be taller

Sydney’s inner suburbs would benefit the most from relaxed height restrictions due to the high land costs, the authors wrote. 

They studied property prices in the five years until 2016 and found surpluses as high as $450,000 in eastern suburbs, Leichhardt and North Sydney in NSW.

“It would be economic to raise building heights by 20 storeys or more above their current heights,” they wrote.

Other big cities are in a better position

Melbourne and Brisbane did not need to revise their planning controls because land is less expensive, the authors wrote. 

“Apartment buildings in those cities are already close to the economically efficient height,” the authors said. 

Did you find this helpful? Why not share this news?



Money Health Newsletter

Subscribe for news, tips and expert opinions to help you make smarter financial decisions

By signing up, you agree to the ratecity.com.au Privacy & Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy


Learn more about home loans

How is the flexibility score calculated?

Points are awarded for different features. More important features get more points. The points are then added up and indexed into a score from 0 to 5.

Who offers 40 year mortgages?

Home loans spanning 40 years are offered by select lenders, though the loan period is much longer than a standard 30-year home loan. You're more likely to find a maximum of 35 years, such as is the case with Teacher’s Mutual Bank

Currently, 40 year home loan lenders in Australia include AlphaBeta Money, BCU, G&C Mutual Bank, Pepper, and Sydney Mutual Bank.

Even though these lengthier loans 35 to 40 year loans do exist on the market, they are not overwhelmingly popular, as the extra interest you pay compared to a 30-year loan can be over $100,000 or more.

What is a redraw fee?

Redraw fees are charged by your lender when you want to take money you have already paid into your mortgage back out. Typically, banks will only allow you to take money out of your loan if you have a redraw facility attached to your loan, and the money you are taking out is part of any additional repayments you’ve made. The average redraw fee is around $19 however there are plenty of lenders who include a number of fee-free redraws a year. Tip: Negative-gearers beware – any money redrawn is often treated as new borrowing for tax purposes, so there may be limits on how you can use it if you want to maximise your tax deduction.

What is a construction loan?

A construction loan is loan taken out for the purpose of building or substantially renovating a residential property. Under this type of loan, the funds are released in stages when certain milestones in the construction process are reached. Once the building is complete, the loan will revert to a standard principal and interest mortgage.

What is bridging finance?

A loan of shorter duration taken to buy a new property before a borrower sells an existing property, usually taken to cover the financial gap that occurs while buying a new property without first selling an older one.

Usually, these loans have higher interest rates and a shorter repayment duration.

How will Real Time Ratings help me find a new home loan?

The home loan market is complex. With almost 4,000 different loans on offer, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to work out which loans work for you.

That’s where Real Time RatingsTM can help. Our system automatically filters out loans that don’t fit your requirements and ranks the remaining loans based on your individual loan requirements and preferences.

Best of all, the ratings are calculated in real time so you know you’re getting the most current information.

What is appreciation or depreciation of property?

The increase or decrease in the value of a property due to factors including inflation, demand and political stability.

Do other comparison sites offer the same service?

Real Time RatingsTM is the only online system that ranks the home loan market based on your personal borrowing preferences. Until now, home loans have been rated based on outdated data. Our system is unique because it reacts to changes as soon as we update our database.

Mortgage Calculator, Deposit

The proportion you have already saved to go towards your home. 

How often is your data updated?

We work closely with lenders to get updates as quick as possible, with updates made the same day wherever possible.

Mortgage Calculator, Loan Results

These are the loans that may be suitable, based on your pre-selected criteria. 

What is the ratings scale?

The ratings are between 0 and 5, shown to one decimal point, with 5.0 as the best. The ratings should be used as an easy guide rather than the only thing you consider. For example, a product with a rating of 4.7 may or may not be better suited to your needs than one with a rating of 4.5, but both are probably much better than one with a rating of 1.2.

How much are repayments on a $250K mortgage?

The exact repayment amount for a $250,000 mortgage will be determined by several factors including your deposit size, interest rate and the type of loan. It is best to use a mortgage calculator to determine your actual repayment size.

For example, the monthly repayments on a $250,000 loan with a 5 per cent interest rate over 30 years will be $1342. For a loan of $300,000 on the same rate and loan term, the monthly repayments will be $1610 and for a $500,000 loan, the monthly repayments will be $2684.

Savings over

Select a number of years to see how much money you can save with different home loans over time.

e.g. To see how much you could save in two years by switching mortgages,  set the slider to 2.